Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Civil Rights
  • The Struggle For Political Equality
2
Martin Luther King to
Louis Farrakhan
  • 1963 - March on Washington - 500,000 hear speeches by civil rights leaders
  • Mostly African-American
  • Most thought integrated society was near
  • Mood reflected by King’s “I have a dream” speech
3
Million Man March (1995)
    • 30 years later, 600,000 black men at U.S. Capitol Building with Louis Farrakhan (Nation of Islam)
    • Farrakhan claimed his Million Man March was to encourage self-reliance among black men

4
Civil Rights Changed from mid 1960s to mid 1990s
    • 1995 - Million Man March reflected civil rights Uncertainty V. Optimism of mid-1960s.
    • Million Man March - harsh separatist temper / reflected racial polarization
5
Civil Rights
  • Civil rights – equal treatment of all citizens / marathon
  • Equality of opportunity - able to participate
  • Equality of condition – eliminate barriers
  • Equality of results – affirmative action / preferential treatment Carry to finish line)
6
Civil Rights Before 1900
  • Initial absence of civil rights
    “Equality” not in the constitution
  • Late 1700s and early 1800s – people  more interested in protecting states from federal government than in protecting individuals with federal government
7
Inequality of Blacks and Women Before Civil War
  • In the south - blacks in slavery - no
  • rights
  • Outside the south - blacks treated as inferiors
  • (1857 - Dred Scott V. Sandford - Dr Emerson)
  • Women could not vote, few allowed on juries / some could not own property / enter into contracts.
8
Civil War Amendments
  • 13th, 14th, 15th – Civil War Amendments guaranteed essential rights to ex-slaves.
  • Civil war amendments ineffective to some
  • Supreme court more interested in property rights than human rights
9
Slaughterhouse Cases (1873)
  • Courts did little to protect individual rights
  • Citizens not protected from state governments
  • Equal protection lost most of its meaning
10
15th Amendment
  • Voting guarantees of the 15th ineffective - Blacks / Poor prevented from voting in the South
    • Poll tax
    • Literacy tests
    • White primaries
11
Women and the
15th Amendment
  • Women worked for the vote / change the 15th. Amendment
  • Supreme court ruled that women’s suffrage not covered by 14th amendment
  • Women’s suffrage continued to grow
  • 1920 - women got the vote with the 19th.
12
Status of Civil Rights
  • Civil rights for minorities:
    Two issues have dominated Civil Rights since the mid-1960s:
      • Ending legal (de-jure) discrimination separation, and exclusion
      • Affirmative actions - to rectify past wrongs
13
1960s - Bill of Rights
  • Supreme Court Restricts the states
  • Boston: Fire-fighters
  • Santa Clara, Ca
  • Dispatch job (Diane Joyce / Paul Johnson)
  • University of Ca Med. School (1977)  Allan Bakke
14
Separate but Equal
  • 1896 – Plessy V. Ferguson – La. Law required blacks to ride in separate rail car
  • De-jure Segregation – by law
  • De-Facto Segregation – self-segregation
  • Rich neighborhoods have better schools, roads, lighting, law enforcement
15
End of Separate but Equal
  • Internment of Japanese - Americans allowed no due process
  • (Korematsu v. U.S.1944)
  • Separate but equal overturned
  • Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka (1954)


16
More Separate but Equal

  • Massive resistance to civil rights in the South
  • President and Congress backed up the Courts:
  • Civil Rights Act of 1964
  • Voting Rights Act of 1965


17
Gender Legislation
  • 1800s – Husband and Wife = one
  • 1920 – 19th Amendment Women can vote
  • 1963 – Equal Pay for Equal Work
  • 1964 – No Sexual / Race bias in hiring
  • 1972 – No Sexual Discrimination in Education
  • 1986 – No Mandatory Retirement at 70 (airlines at 60?)
18
Today’s Standards
  • Doctrine on discrimination
    • Use of race in law or regulation will trigger Strict Scrutiny from the courts
    • Government can defend discrimination if there is a compelling government interest
19
Affirmative Action
  • Government actions favor racial minorities with preferred treatment to redress past injustices
  • Programs that narrowly redress specific violations are ok / programs that address societal racism are not
20
Civil Rights for Women
  • Warren(1953-1969) little for women’s rights
  • Burger (1969-1986) strict scrutiny to sex discrimination cases
    • Strict scrutiny endangers traditional sex roles
    • Ordinary scrutiny would allow some sex discrimination
21
Abortion Rights
  • Roe v. Wade (1973) - abortion a constitutional issue about mothers rights
    • Discussion of abortion increased during the 1960s
    • Court prohibited states from interfering with  abortions in the first two tri- mesters (can outlaw in 3rd)
    • Justice Blackmun’s opinion based on right to privacy (through 4th, 9th, and 14th)
22
Pro-life groups mobilized
 after Roe
  • Anti-abortion politics with two cases:
    • Webster v. Reproductive Health Services (1989)
    • Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992)
  • Court allowed states to restrict abortions, but affirmed principles of Roe
  • Abortion a dominant issue in confirmations of judges / justices
23
Sexual Harassment
  • 1980 - Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) – if gender a condition of employment or promotion violates 1964 Civil Rights Act
  • Supreme Court / sexual harassment.
    • Workers only had to prove that the
    • work environment was hostile or
    • abusive
24
Broadening Civil Rights
  • Elderly and Disabled:
  • Federal / State laws bar some mandatory retirement / Courts strike down some hiring practices based on age without compelling reasons
  • Disabled Americans won passage of Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990
25
More Broadening Civil Rights
  • 1989 – Free Expression - Gregory Lee Johnson / Republican National Convention (desecration of national symbol)
  • Arm Bands, Burning Bras, Draft Cards, Clothing
26
More Broadening Civil Rights
  • “Actionable Words” – case by case
  • 1964 - NY Times v. Sullivan (public figure) Sullivan (Montgomery, Ala. city commissioner, sued over full page ad claiming mistreatment of blacks. (most of ad was false) – Lost in Supreme Court
  • “Beyond Reasonable Doubt Standard”


27
More Broadening Civil Rights
  • 1919 – Oliver W. Holmes
  • Clear and Present Danger Test
  • Imminent Violence / Threat
  • Can’t Yell Fire in Crowded Theatre / Can’t Offer to Hire Hit Man
  • Your Rights v. Someone Else’s Liberty?


28
More Broadening Civil Rights
  • Public’s need / right to know v. right to fair trial?
  • Reporters w/Constitutional immunity about sources?
  • Even if info necessary to fair trial?
  • Change of venue? Small town press?
29
Gays and lesbians
    • Rights for gays and lesbians (political power)
    • The struggle for gay and lesbian rights remains on the American political agenda

30
Civil Rights and Democracy
  • Equality today is equal to popular sovereignty and political liberty in 1800’s
  • Equality not a high priority until 1960s
  • American life still unequal / unrepresentative
  • Formal political equality is real